CFD Online Discussion Forums

CFD Online Discussion Forums (http://www.cfd-online.com/Forums/)
-   ANSYS Meshing & Geometry (http://www.cfd-online.com/Forums/ansys-meshing/)
-   -   [GAMBIT] Mesh error while trying to read it using Fluent (http://www.cfd-online.com/Forums/ansys-meshing/111343-mesh-error-while-trying-read-using-fluent.html)

dk_damo January 4, 2013 04:47

Mesh error while trying to read it using Fluent
 
I designed and mesh my combustor chamber using gambit then i tried reading my case with fluent but it fails ,did all i can to remesh or change things but still fails.
This is the error below i got when reading the case.


Loading "C:\Fluent.Inc\fluent6.3.26\lib\fl_s1119.dmp"
Done.


> Reading "C:\Users\dk\Desktop\combustor final 18DEC\combustor with fuel inlet\combustor with fuel inlet.msh"...
102703 nodes.
75 mixed mass-flow-inlet faces, zone 3.
6292 mixed wall faces, zone 4.
17202 mixed wall faces, zone 5.
14044 mixed wall faces, zone 6.
18556 mixed wall faces, zone 7.
272 mixed pressure-outlet faces, zone 8.
126 mixed mass-flow-inlet faces, zone 9.
560306 mixed interior faces, zone 11.
269232 mixed cells, zone 2.

Building...
grid,
Note: Separating wall zone 7 into zones 7 and 1.
wall.3 -> wall.3 (7) and wall.3:001 (1)
Removing 75 unreferenced faces, zone 3.
Cell Centroid is xc 51.793619 yc -0.799997 zc -4.593363
WARNING: no face with given nodes. Thread 2, cell 185542
Error: Build_Grid: grid error.
Clearing partially read grid.

Error: Null Domain Pointer

Error Object: ()

-mAx- January 4, 2013 04:59

can you post a picture of your geometry?
did you split it? (sounds connectivity problem)

PSYMN January 5, 2013 13:13

Null pointer means that you have an uncovered face... A volume element at the boundary without an adjacent shell element for Fluent to apply the wall boundary to (or a shell without a line boundary in 2D).

Maybe mAx can tell you how you got that with Gambit (it is easy to make that mistake in ICEM CFD :() Did you delete any shells?

dk_damo January 5, 2013 14:12

Quote:

Originally Posted by PSYMN (Post 400222)
Null pointer means that you have an uncovered face... A volume element at the boundary without an adjacent shell element for Fluent to apply the wall boundary to (or a shell without a line boundary in 2D).

Maybe mAx can tell you how you got that with Gambit (it is easy to make that mistake in ICEM CFD :() Did you delete any shells?

Thank you,YES. The error started when i deleted an earlier swirler then i designed a new modified one which i replaced.

-mAx- January 7, 2013 02:12

Then the old design may not be deleted properly, and it's surface mesh may remain

dk_damo January 7, 2013 07:42

thanks
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by -mAx- (Post 400412)
Then the old design may not be deleted properly, and it's surface mesh may remain

Thank you Max,did you get the files i sent to you?

-mAx- January 7, 2013 10:44

Quote:

Originally Posted by dk_damo (Post 400467)
Thank you Max,did you get the files i sent to you?

no
private message?

dk_damo January 7, 2013 10:52

Quote:

Originally Posted by -mAx- (Post 400500)
no
private message?

Yes,Max i sent it private maybe i mistakenly sent to a different email,can you kindly confirm your email to me,i wanted to send the cad n mesh files which i still get that error i posted . thanks again

dk_damo January 7, 2013 11:26

email
 
hi, Max i sent .thanks

-mAx- January 9, 2013 02:18

ok not surprised that you get errors in fluent.
you have to restart from beginning. (split problem, connectivity problem and topology problem).
Did you build the geometry in Gambit or did you import anything from cad?

dk_damo January 9, 2013 05:31

hi
 
Thanks Max i did it in Gambit

-mAx- January 9, 2013 05:35

describe shortly how (till you get geometry without any decomposition)

dk_damo January 9, 2013 06:11

hi
 
Max what happen was i designed and meshed a swirler and a combustor separately then combined them together i was able to run a case in fluent without a problem then i noticed i needed to modify the swirler with introduction of a boundary called fuel in and this swirler i entirely new from the earlier one then i tried to combine both as i did thats when fluent failed to read it.

-mAx- January 9, 2013 06:26

Quote:

Originally Posted by dk_damo (Post 400912)
i designed and meshed a swirler and a combustor separately then combined them together i was able to run a case in fluent without a problem

I am curious to see the fluent results.
Basically in your model you have an outer box and a swirler, and I can move the swirler anywhere whithout Gambit checked anything.
That means that Gambit treats the outer domain without any hollow , and on the other hand, Gambit has another separate domain: the swirler

From beginning you need to model the outer domain, and also the swirler (but this one as solid). Then substract the outer domain with the solid.
Once it is done, you can go and split.

Do you have a sketch of your model (not gambit)

dk_damo January 9, 2013 07:22

hi
 
Hi,Max i sent more info about the problem to your email.thank you very much))

-mAx- January 10, 2013 02:34

-build the combustion chamber as solid first like page 7 (take care of thickness)
-build the swirler separately as solid and place it to its right place.
Once you assembly is done (as solid), create a bounding box and substract the assembly from the box.
It would extract the fluid domain, and you could start from a clean geometry.

dk_damo January 10, 2013 07:32

hi
 
Ok,thank you Max


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 12:02.