Blocking domain and blade
3 Attachment(s)
Hello,
I write this post to see if any of you could advise me on the blocking strategy is appropriate. I'm trying to mesh this domain (image1,2) Attachment 19578 Attachment 19579. Before I do this, I want to split it the whole domain into 3 sections and then mesh them separately. Now I show the first of it (image 3). Attachment 19580 To be clear what I do in this case attached this video. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TMbkw...ature=youtu.be I am delighted to tell me what I'm doing wrong or if the strategy is not adequate. I make an o-grid but then if I want to have a sharp trailing edge I have to collapse blocks and I think that worsens the cylinder .. I do not know what would be the optimal strategy. Thank you in advance |
You started well, but i would not have collapsed the block. don't do it . at the end , it's like you are blocking a wing. and there multiple way of doing this. it's up to you. what i will suggest . Just before collapsing the block, or merging anything, look for how to deal with the trailing edge in 3d. there are a lot and a lot of thread about this.
i wish i can help, but i'm busy these days. may be in the week end. you also started some threads before about blocking of wings , how did it go ? can't you apply it for this geometry. Also, you are splitting your hole geometry in three. how are you gonna reassemble the mesh ?? |
You're right, it's like a wing, but as in this video
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EknKVAJGEJ8 collapse them is not a bad idea if there is a sharp edge. Besides, this piece of blade is twisted ... I donīt know if Iīll get good results if not collaps the blocks. Thank you for your feedback. Yes, I made those little cases as examples. I've done all the exercises in ANSYS Tutorial Manual but actually before start the actual domain meshing I want to practice with these geometries. Yes, I get the meshing but always remaining elements of poor quality near the trailing edge. I think I explained wrong. Yes, I separate the domain into 3 parts. But only because I want to mesh them separately, like examples a little more real for my real domain. Then, I want the take the whole problem and mesh it. |
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TMbkw...ature=youtu.be
Blocking this piece of geometry is very much simple. Just a 5 min job. When you will make the full scale blocking, this approach wont help you much. |
2 Attachment(s)
Hi FJSJ, I'm doing a similar case of a wind turbine blade with sharp trailing edge. Have you found negative volumes around the blade? I'm practicing with a straight (not twisted yet) NACA cylinder some blocking strategies but I cannot avoid negative volumes even if I get a min quality of 0.4. I've tried both, collapsed and not collapsed trailing block but I've been suggested to use a collapsed one for such a sharp edge. You can see two of my blocking in the pics, both gave negative volumes.
|
thank you for your comment Far. Yes... iīve been thinking about this. I mean, i can mesh first part of my domain separately but when I have to do the whole domain it isnīt useful. anyway, I'd like meshing, as an exercise to practice. The link you left I think it isnīt works.I would like to see it, if is possible.
|
Hi, Far.
I am also meshing a twisted wind turbine blade with a sharp trailing edge, and there are a lot of negative element at the trailing part. Would you give me some tips? by the way, I really like to see the video you posted if it works! Best regards, Ye |
Hi Bollonga,
Did you solve this problem? Now I have the same problem as you. Hope you can give me some suggestions if you have solved it. Best regards, Ye |
Hi kiddmax,
try to attach some pictures about your geom |
Quote:
We solved same issue in another thread and it clearly shows that different topology is required to handle sharp TE http://www.cfd-online.com/Forums/ans...mesh-wing.html |
1 Attachment(s)
Quote:
Thank you for your reply. For now, there is some problem between the sharp trailing edge and the hub. I want to collapse the block at the sharp tailing edge, which result in disorder mesh. Look at my pics. Meanwhile, I am not very sure about the block Strategies about this geometry. Can you give me some guideline? I can not post my tin and prj file because of exceeding the size Best regards, Ye |
I would suggest to give some finite thickness to blade at TE.
|
did you guys solve the problem at the trailing edge part?
|
Hi Cesar,
did you watch the video in first post? Itīs not the best solution at all, but.. at least you can think in similar approaches. |
Hi FJSJ,
I have not watched the video. I just read some portions of the thread and thought that I may be able to give some ideas with the trailing edge issue. Regards |
Hi Cesar,
Ok.Itīs just... thinking about your blocking approach. I think that if you want to get good quality in trailing edge you have to "collapse blocks" (like 8:10 in the next video) ANSYS 12.1 (Part 2 of 3) ICEM CFD Hexa 2D Airfoil meshing Take a look to looking for some similar threads. For example, if I donīt remember wrong, there is an very useful approach (at least for me) Ralen Approach |
Yes, I have seen that video many times. I also checked the Ralen approach you are telling me about when I had problems with meshing a geometry for my thesis. It is a very good example that Far recommended me. If you are using a C-type mesh topology, I could say that collapsing the blocks from the trailing edge up to the far field can help you to improve the quality of the cells.
Regards |
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 08:09. |