|April 10, 2012, 17:17||
Unreliable Torque in CFX
For a fluid coupling device that is just a closed rotor-stator system, I have found CFX to show good results for one model (within 5%), BUT for another 2 devices of similar construction it is 3 orders of magnitude off with the same procedure!
I have gone thru the following checks:
1. Check that all meshing and setup for all geometries are the same.
2. Check several mesh sizes from a total of 1-3 million for a single period.
3. Steady state as initial guess with transient to follow once decent convergence is reached. Time step is determined by (2*pi/number of periods)/rotational speed. 10 coefficient loops, second order everything.
4. Convergence is always to at least 5e-6.
5. Axis checked and rechecked to make sure its always rotating about the proper circle center and at the proper lever arm.
6. Boundary conditions same as successful run, physically realistic.
7. Rotation in correct direction (i.e. right hand rule).
I ultimately feel like there is some trick to using the torque feature, or it just plain doesn't work for all cases. Any help would be immensely appreciated.
|April 12, 2012, 01:32||
Join Date: Apr 2011
Posts: 67Rep Power: 6
Are you checking the torque about you axis of rotation in all cases. See it in post and not in a monitor point ( if you are doing that now )
|Thread||Thread Starter||Forum||Replies||Last Post|
|Modifying pressure field in CFX||akultane||CFX||2||January 13, 2010 15:42|
|heat generation in CFX||Ema||CFX||4||August 7, 2009 05:39|
|Electronics Enclosure Analysis with CFX||Simulation Engineer||CFX||1||April 22, 2009 11:08|
|CFX 10's solutions differ from CFX 5.7's||Atit Koonsrisuk||CFX||4||July 26, 2006 11:59|
|CFX 4.4 installation problem||Pandu Sattvika||CFX||1||December 1, 2001 05:07|