CFD Online Discussion Forums

CFD Online Discussion Forums (
-   FLOW-3D (
-   -   Size ration in a 2D analysis (

Marcus.filho October 22, 2013 08:16

Size ration in a 2D analysis
Dear all,

Im conducting a 2D analysis of a spillway to have some preliminary results and I ran into a doubt.

When we ahave a 3d mesh there are certain size ratio relationships we must follow in order to have good results. How does that work in a 2D mesh? For example, if I have a 2D analysis in the XZ plane with cels with 0.25m by 0.25m, can I have one cell in the Y direction 1m wide or is is better to have a 0.25m cell in the Y direction as well? Does the size ratio matter in this case?

I hope I made myself clear. Thank you in advance.


JBurnham October 22, 2013 10:41

The size of the cell in the 2-D direction doesn't matter. FLOW-3D tracks volume of flow, so if the y-direction cell size is 1 m, then it makes converting 3-D volumes and 2-D areas easier.

Marcus.filho October 22, 2013 19:27

Thank you Jeff. So it is actually a good practice in 2D analysis always to have a 1 meter size cell in the dimension which is not beeing modeled?

JBurnham October 27, 2013 23:38

Yeah. It's a good thing, at least for interpreting the results. If it's a 3-D model, cubic cells are better, but 2-D it doesn't matter.

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 07:32.