# Errors in CFD

 Register Blogs Members List Search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read

 April 15, 2000, 09:37 Errors in CFD #1 Lily Kabanj Guest   Posts: n/a I have some questions regarding errors in CFD simulation and is hopeful that someone can point me in the right direction. (1) What kind of error should one consider when presenting a CFD simulation results and (2) how do one calculate/estimate the error(s) in a 3-D FLUENT simulation ? Many thanks in advance.

 April 15, 2000, 12:36 Re: Errors in CFD #3 John C. Chien Guest   Posts: n/a (1). Normally, you need a mesh to do CFD calculations. If the solution is a function of the mesh used, then you will have errors. It is a must that when you present the solution, the solution is independent of the particular mesh you created and used. (2). There is no need to address the absolute accuracy of the results, because within CFD one can use linearized potential equation, full potential equation, Euler equation, parabolized equation, Navier-Stokes equations, etc. As long as the solution of the equation is independent of the mesh and is repeatable, then the solution to that equation is accurate. (3). So, the only way to estimate the error in solution of the equation, is to try a few different meshes and check the solution sensitivity vs the meshes. (4). If you are solving the real world problem, then comparison with the test data is probably the only way to go. Otherwise, CFD solutions are just solutions to a set of equations, including some physical models if required. (5). To make it easier to understand, if your fine mesh solution is different from your coarse mesh solution, then you can say that the coarse mesh solution has higher errors in it.( it is an over-simplified example, so a systematic study in mesh independency is essential. Otherwise everyone will be presenting the 20x20x20 solution, which is much easier to obtain than that of 100x100x100 solution.

 April 17, 2000, 01:45 Re: Errors in CFD #4 Fred Uckfield Guest   Posts: n/a "All models are wrong, some are useful." G. E. Box Be more productive by looking for the use in models instead of spending time questioning their validility. OK, OK, I know, if the quatitive accuracy is too bad then the usefulness diminishes quickly. Depending on what industry you are applying CFD in you may well be surprised at how innaccurate you can be whilst still finding use in your models, therefore being more a more productive employee, serving your company better and so being a postivive contributer to the human race. Fred.

 April 17, 2000, 10:59 Re: Errors in CFD #5 LW Guest   Posts: n/a I still remeber the paradox quoted in Fluent TG a few years ago: "Nobody belives analysis results except the analyst, everybody belives testing results except the tester" (may not exact). The comments for the Error question have been excellent. I think there are only a few things you can do: 1) Make sure your physical problem is well represented by the mathematical model (equations), 2) Make sure the mathematical model is numerically well converged. 3) Check the model results agains testing data, EXPERIENCE (IMPORTANT)or even the other modeling resutls that you know to be true.

 April 18, 2000, 01:30 Re: Errors in CFD #7 Lily Kabanj Guest   Posts: n/a Thank you for all your comments on my question. I appreciate it very much. I am the only cfd user in a research group whose backbone work are mainly physical experiments and from time to time, I find myself having to justify tbe validity of the results of the numerical simulation. The other reason was certain fluid mechanics journal will no receive papers on numerical work unless some "error analysis" has been done, although it wasn't clear what kind of analysis is required. Once again, thank you for your time in answering my question. Further comments from other gurus and experts are most welcome =).

 April 25, 2000, 08:54 Re: Errors in CFD #8 Althea Guest   Posts: n/a LW, (or anyone else), Can you please tell me where you got your quote, I don't know what the Fluent TG is. Regards Althea

 May 1, 2000, 07:52 Re: Errors in CFD #9 LW Guest   Posts: n/a It was in either Fluent Tutorial Guide or User's Guide (1995 version). I believe it was quoted from some other source by the Guide. Thx!

 Thread Tools Display Modes Linear Mode

 Posting Rules You may not post new threads You may not post replies You may not post attachments You may not edit your posts BB code is On Smilies are On [IMG] code is On HTML code is OffTrackbacks are On Pingbacks are On Refbacks are On Forum Rules

 Similar Threads Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post Chris R. Kleijn Main CFD Forum 16 October 2, 2000 09:15 Chris R. Kleijn Main CFD Forum 0 September 13, 2000 04:48 Chris R. Kleijn Main CFD Forum 0 August 21, 2000 04:49 John C. Chien Main CFD Forum 19 October 6, 1999 11:57 Tareq Al-shaalan Main CFD Forum 10 June 12, 1999 23:27

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 19:34.