
[Sponsors] 
October 24, 2012, 10:18 
Question about grid independence study

#1 
Senior Member
Meimei Wang
Join Date: Jul 2012
Posts: 494
Rep Power: 8 
Hi,
Why we need 3 points on the parabolic grid independence study curve? Why not only 2? Why all of the 3 points have to be on the parabolic curve? In the case that my medium mesh simulation result is very close to the fine mesh but my coarse mesh is totally out of the parabolic curve, why I still can't say my fine mesh is good enough to use? Thank you very much!
__________________
Best regards, Meimei 

October 25, 2012, 09:04 

#2 
Senior Member
Jonas T. Holdeman, Jr.
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Knoxville, Tennessee
Posts: 108
Rep Power: 10 
If I understand your question correctly, the convergence rate upon mesh refinement, assumed parabolic in your case, is an assymptotic relation, valid only for sufficiently refined meshes. Three points on a parabolic curve doesn't prove your mesh is fine enough for the relation to apply, but may give you some confidence that it is. Two points don't tell you anything about assymptotic convergence rate.


October 25, 2012, 10:15 

#3  
Senior Member
Meimei Wang
Join Date: Jul 2012
Posts: 494
Rep Power: 8 
Why three points on parabolic curve still can't prove my mesh is good enough? What can prove that?
Quote:
__________________
Best regards, Meimei 

October 25, 2012, 14:02 

#4 
Senior Member
Jonas T. Holdeman, Jr.
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Knoxville, Tennessee
Posts: 108
Rep Power: 10 
Suppose the convergence was actually linear, given asymptotically by a0*h+a1*h^2+a2*h^3+...., but where a0 was very small. Then there might be a range of h where a0*h << a1*h^2. Then in this range the assymptptic convergence would appear to be quadratic. But if you made h small enough, the linear term would begin to dominate. So you can't prove by giving examples that the convergence is quadratic, but if points continue to lie on the quadratic curve as you decrease h, you might gain confidence that quadratic convergence is indeed the case.


October 25, 2012, 14:13 

#5 
Senior Member
Filippo Maria Denaro
Join Date: Jul 2010
Posts: 2,607
Rep Power: 33 
See Section 3.9 in the book of Ferziger and Peric, three grids give you an estimation of the rate of convergence


Thread Tools  
Display Modes  


Similar Threads  
Thread  Thread Starter  Forum  Replies  Last Post 
What is meant by Grid Independence Study?  Khan  FLUENT  10  July 2, 2015 22:40 
Grid Independence of Boundary Layer  Luigi_  STARCCM+  7  January 15, 2012 15:40 
grid independence questions  lucifer  FLUENT  0  December 14, 2009 20:59 
Grid independence  hbf  FLUENT  3  July 21, 2009 05:42 
Vorticity plot in grid refinement study  CH  Main CFD Forum  3  May 22, 2007 12:35 