CFD Online Discussion Forums

CFD Online Discussion Forums (http://www.cfd-online.com/Forums/)
-   Main CFD Forum (http://www.cfd-online.com/Forums/main/)
-   -   hexahedra elements & accuracy??????? (http://www.cfd-online.com/Forums/main/11392-hexahedra-elements-accuracy.html)

vijesh joshi May 9, 2006 10:13

hexahedra elements & accuracy???????
 
Hello friends. I have a question. Is there any relation between the type of element used and the accuracy?? I am using CFX software. In the help files, it has not been given. Please help me. Regards, VVJ.

ericnutsch December 3, 2009 14:01

hexahedral vs tetrahedral
 
Serval professors have informed me that a Hexahedral mesh is more acurate in the boundary layer. Tetrahedrals have less skew computational issues and are better over irregular geometry or when expanding the size of the cells away from the geometry(size function).

I am curious however as to how much more accurate they are; since in the opensource world tetrahedrals are much easier to generate.

(Anyone) Do you think it would take twice as many
tetrahedrals, three times as many, four, or more to be equivalent to
the quality of a hexahedral boundary layer mesh?

CapSizer December 3, 2009 17:12

Well, in real life this is actually a very complex question with no simple answer. There are theoretical methods that should give you the relative accuracies, but in my experience practical concerns tend to override these. For example, it can depend on the topology of whatever it is that you are meshing. When it comes to something very regular like a 3D wing, for example, a tetrahedral grid may require 10 times as many cells as a hexa grid, for equivalent accuracy.

It is also noticeable how fast certain types of unstructured hexa grids will converge, by virtue of minimal skewness and good cell aspect ratios. I have sometimes seen a poor quality hexa grid produce better results than a good tetra grid. It rather depends on where the bad cells are, and how resistant the solver is to being tripped up by these bad cells.

kingjewel1 December 3, 2009 17:32

Can I refer you to this paper by Hefny and OOka: CFD analysis of pollutant dispersion around buildings: effect of cell geometry, Building and Environment 44 (2009)

ericnutsch December 4, 2009 15:37

hexahedral mesh is _x as acurate
 
Thanks CapSizer! You are the first person to put forth a number. 10 times means a whole lot more than "more". Im not going to base any calcultions on it, but it is good to have a feeling for the numbers before you choose a direction.

Thanks for the ref kingjewel1. Here is the abstract if anyone else is interested:
http://cat.inist.fr/?aModele=afficheN&cpsidt=21358896



If anyone else has had different experiences please post them. Thanks!


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 14:57.