CFD Online Discussion Forums

CFD Online Discussion Forums (
-   Main CFD Forum (
-   -   Mixed models in LES (

Pradeep March 26, 2003 07:43

Mixed models in LES
Hi guys,

I have a question regarding mixedmodels in LES.

I understood that in LES we only model the deviator part of the subgrid tensor in the case of eddy viscosity SGS models (Smagorinsky type). we don't model the isetropic part and it is added to the pressure, i.e.we will have a modiefied pressure.

but in the case of scale similarity models like Baldina we consider entire subgrid tensor.i.e,

tauij=scale similarity term from bardina (=Lij).

but In the case of mixedmodels we have the formula like

deviator part of tauij=smagorinsky model+(Lij-1/3Lkk*deltaij)

where deltaij=1 when i=j otherwise it is 0.

my question is Are we going treat subgrid tensor similar way like Smagorinsky model,i.e, we will have a modified pressure or we required some other approach.

Please answer the question.



Mayank Tyagi March 26, 2003 15:10

Re: Mixed models in LES
Hi, You are right in treating SGS tensor by using the deviatoric part only (yes, you'll get a modified pressure). In evaluating the model coefficient, we need the deviatoric part...ref: Vreman et al (1996), On the formulation of dynamic mixed models, physics of fluids. However, you could gain more insight from Lkk (trace of scale similar term) about the subgrid turbulent kinetic energy...ref: Knaepen and Carati (2001), physics of fluids (also in proceedings of 3rd AFOSR conf. on DNS/LES 2001) hope this helps Mayank

euler March 27, 2003 03:15

Re: Mixed models in LES

In principle you can model also the full tensor, not only the anisotropic part of the tensor. With Smagorinsky-like models this is not possible because S_ij is traceless. And then you model only the anisotropic part of the tensor.

In mixed models you can model the full tensor or only the anisotropic part. It is up to you. For example in Sarghini et al 99 Physics of Fluids the model is:

tau_ij = L_ij + eddy viscosity term

Of course the Pressure will not be the real Pressure but some mixed function of P and the subgrid turbulent kinetic energy. (Because the eddy viscosity term remains traceless)


S. Crofts. March 27, 2003 05:56

Re: Mixed models in LES
Hi there,

Where can I find a text (preferably a text book) that describes how the trace part of the tensor is absorbed into the pressure term? Also,

Thanking you all.

Pradeep March 28, 2003 04:56

Re: Mixed models in LES
Hi guys,

Thank you very much for your help.



All times are GMT -4. The time now is 18:17.