|
[Sponsors] |
August 9, 2010, 19:37 |
Is there such thing as a CFD "User"?
|
#1 |
New Member
Ryan Z. Davis
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Idaho Falls, Idaho, United States
Posts: 11
Rep Power: 16 |
Hi all,
I just had a philosophical debate with a fellow grad student about this subject. I believe that a person cannot just "pick up" some CFD software and use it. Even if they generate a result that mimics an experimental result I would not trust the computation. I was just wondering what are your thoughts on this. Thanks for your reply, ryzd |
|
August 9, 2010, 21:31 |
|
#2 |
New Member
Scott
Join Date: Aug 2010
Posts: 2
Rep Power: 0 |
I don't think that CFD is any different from the other tools that are used in industry. Anyone can use the tool if properly trained. There are many things that can cause an erroneous CFD solution, but that can be said for a structural tool like ANSYS.
Bottom line is that using a complex tool requires good understanding of not only the tool, but the underlying assumptions. For example: In structures, you need to be able to draw a free body diagram for complex loading scenarios. In CFD you need to understand the implications of the chosen grid and turbulence model. I think that to learn, someone must use the tool. In college, you learn theory and then the tool. In the workforce you typically learn the tool with guidance from an expert, then you gradually learn the theory. Just a difference in approach. |
|
August 11, 2010, 10:22 |
|
#3 |
Member
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 44
Rep Power: 17 |
I agree with Scott, but there's even more. Are you asking if someone can pick up a CFD tool and predict water flow in a pipe or are you asking if they can pick up a tool and solve a problem with multiple phases, complex chemistry, heat transfer, liquid films, droplets, moving boundaries with fluid-structure interaction added for good measure? I would hope almost anyone with a absolute minimum of training could do the first. Obviously they aren't going to do the second and somewhere in between is a line between what's reasonable and what isn't for someone with not a lot of background.
|
|
August 12, 2010, 06:59 |
|
#4 | |
Senior Member
Rami Ben-Zvi
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 155
Rep Power: 17 |
Quote:
|
||
August 14, 2010, 18:14 |
|
#5 |
Senior Member
John Chawner
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Fort Worth, Texas, USA
Posts: 275
Rep Power: 18 |
Let's demystify the question somewhat by replacing "CFD" with "paintbrush". Is there such a thing as a paintbrush user? Yes, certainly there is. Lot's of people are competent painters who can go down to the Home Depot, buy painting supplies, and do a great job on their house or a living room or a kid's project.
Is this same person going to be able to paint the next masterpiece that hangs in your favorite art museum? Probably not. CFD is a tool like any other tool. In the hands of a competent, trained user it can produce good engineering results. You wouldn't give a toddler a brush and a bucket of paint and set them loose in your house. Nor should you give an untrained engineer a CFD code and pray for good results. Now, I realize there are caveats so let's not argue the analogy. There are child prodigies who can outpaint most of us. And there are engineers who can pickup a CFD code and get good results right out of the box. But when you turn to the high-end, one-off types of CFD problems, your CFD user probably isn't the one you want running the show. You want a CFD expert, a dedicated analyst who knows how to make the CFD code do what's needed and who can interpret the results.
__________________
John Chawner / jrc@pointwise.com / www.pointwise.com Blog: http://blog.pointwise.com/ on Twitter: @jchawner |
|
Tags |
black box, cfd user |
Thread Tools | Search this Thread |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
CFD Wiki - We Need More Help | Jonas Larsson | Main CFD Forum | 13 | September 13, 2005 18:36 |
is there any money in CFD? | T | Main CFD Forum | 35 | May 9, 2001 20:35 |
CFD for fans & blower housings | David Carroll | Main CFD Forum | 8 | August 24, 2000 18:25 |
PC vs. Workstation | Tim Franke | Main CFD Forum | 5 | September 29, 1999 16:01 |
Which is better to develop in-house CFD code or to buy a available CFD package. | Tareq Al-shaalan | Main CFD Forum | 10 | June 13, 1999 00:27 |