CFD Online Discussion Forums

CFD Online Discussion Forums (http://www.cfd-online.com/Forums/)
-   Main CFD Forum (http://www.cfd-online.com/Forums/main/)
-   -   convergence criteria (http://www.cfd-online.com/Forums/main/9683-convergence-criteria.html)

Andrew Hayes August 12, 2005 13:58

convergence criteria
 
I am having trouble deciding on what kind of convergence criteria I should apply to my program. I have used MathCAD to develop a 2-D implicit finite difference program using the voticity/stream function method to get velocities. I am currently solving it for the flow in an enclosure with a moving top. In the program I can set determine how large my grid is, but I can't decide on how to set a convergence-criteria that will tell it when to stop iterating. Originally I was able to set the number of iterations. Now, I have it itereate until the absolute value of the center node's x-velocity, Ux, minus the previous iteration's Ux, is below a certain number, ie - .0001. I am not sure if that is a good method or not.

Any suggestions would be helpful.

thanks

m. malik August 12, 2005 15:47

Re: convergence criteria
 
A criterion based on just the difference doesn't seem to be right. I use criterion of the follwing forms in variuos iterative problems: Sum(f_new - f_old)^2/Sum(f_new)^2 < a small value or Sum|f_new - f_old|/Sum|f_new| < a small value where Sum = sum on all the nodes

f = field variable new, old = current and previous iteration values

Mani August 12, 2005 19:24

Re: convergence criteria
 
Whatever you do, don't just look at one point in the domain. If you're solving an equation f(x,y,...) = 0, determine the R.M.S. residual over the entire domain. Malik's equations provide an equivalent approach, but the exponent 2 should be inside the summation.

Apart from that: Your initial approach to fix a number of iterations was actually more robust. You should still impose an upper limit for the number of iterations, because you never know whether a set residual can even be reached. Always observe the residual, but don't make a fixed residual your only condition for termination.

ramp August 13, 2005 04:27

Re: convergence criteria
 
check it out: http://www.cfd-online.com/Forum/main...cgi?read=38497


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 01:14.