1.5.x/1.5.x.git/1.5-dev/openfoam-extend confusion
Hi!
I am confused about the various sources of extended and development versions of OpenFoam. Moreover, I don't find solvers like MRFSimpleFoam, and conjugateHeatFoam is sometimes called chtMultiRegionFoam, and uses different coupling techniques. Which is the recommended download of OpenFoam, if I am interested in recent active developments?
And finally, what is the status of 1.6-dev? Has 1.5-dev been updated after the release of OpenFoam 1.6? Will it be updated? Which will be the recommended place to download 1.6-dev? Regards, Mike |
Hi,
Hrv Jasak is definitivly working on 1.6-dev or "extend". But the release date is not clear. Most likely shortly after the Openfoam Workshop June 21-24 2010 in Gothenburg. You can expect that 1.6-dev will have new capabilaties. Read http://web.student.chalmers.se/group...tract2OFW5.pdf and you will get an idea of what is going to come with the next release. You are free to install both flavors of Openfoam next to another, and some people did that via "alias" in their ".bashrc". =>search for "alias" in this forum and you will find a guide. Both flavors of OF are actively developing, you have to choose what is more important for you. (GGI -> 1.5-dev) elvis |
Greetings Mike,
I don't know every detail, but AFAIK, you have two primary sources for OpenFOAM:
Best regards, Bruno |
Quote:
OpenFOAM(r) is officially developed by OpenCFD(r), whose releases are named as follows: 1.y (for example 1.6) --> main release 1.6.x --> git version, which contains updates with respect to the main release Then there is an informal fork (I say informal because a fork has to be announced, and this one wasn't, at least to my knowledge), called "OpenFOAM-dev" and/or "OpenFOAM-extend", which splits in a set of SVN subrepositories. I won't comment on the choice of "forking without forking and keeping ambiguous names" :D Quote:
Quote:
I use OpenCFD's version because I find it more convenient (It has what I need, git is more convenient than SVN for me, clear definition of stable functionalities) , but it is a question of taste and needs. Quote:
Quote:
Best, |
Thank you for all the answers!
Let me summarize to see if there are no misunderstandings:
I wish forum and wiki contributions stated more explicitly whether they refer to the official or to the dev version. If somebody could add a table to the wiki which shows the differences like conjugateHeatFoam<->chtMultiRegionFoam and also shows a timeline of solvers like icoDyMFoam from OF-1.4.1 to OF-1.6 (with recommendations which solver replaces icoDyMFoam in OF1.6, for example), this would be of great help. Regards, Mike |
Quote:
For the stuff on the Wiki if it says 1.5 then most of the time 1.5-dev is true also Quote:
http://openfoamwiki.net/index.php/Ma...ions_differ.3F or http://openfoamwiki.net/index.php/Main_OFextendFeatures explain it? In the collaborative spirit of the Wiki you could start such a table with the stuff you learned so far and encourage people to contribute Bernhard |
Quote:
Quote:
Best, |
Quote:
Quote:
I am often wondering what people are talking about because I can't find solvers like icoDyMFoam, conjugateHeatFoam, icoFsiFoam, ... Such a table could quickly clarify which versions I could choose from if I need those solvers. Does this sound reasonable? The two links above give me some more information, so that I think that I can now start preparing such a table for the solvers which I have used so far. Regards, Mike |
Quote:
Quote:
Of course such a table could be quite useful. But also a system of token pages "pisoFoam: the solver formerly known as icoFoam" could be useful Bernhard |
Quick thought: If only extensions were "plugins" or, to make it simpler, "patches" to the official release, this problem would not exist. Of course it adds some work on who writes the extensions, especially in the testing stage, but with some automation it is probably not that bad.
Any chance this will happen? |
Dear Foamers,
Has OF-1.6-dev or OF-1.6-ext been released yet ? |
Hi Jitao,
Well, I'm not sure about an "official 1.6-dev/extend", but on the extend home page you can find the svn repo for OF-extend ... |
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 23:19. |