Gather/scatter in boundary code
I have a implementation issue, which gives me a lot of problems. I need to perform a bit of manual exchange of parallel data in my code, because of two boundaries, which are physically connected, but they are not necessarily placed on the same processor. For that I am using the gatherList and scatterList code, and the following is a dummy example of it:
It should be said that irrespectively of where I use this piece of code, it compiles.
Any help on this problem is greatly appreciated.
I just wanted to post the solution, however, as it is a work-around, I would still very much like to get an explanation on the behaviour of gather-/scatterList inside a boundary condition.
1. Apply gather/scatterList on a List<scalarField> in the solver.
2. Concatenate the List<scalarField> into a single scalarField, where the contribution from each processor is placed behind each other.
3. Put this information into a IOField<scalar>.
4. Since the IOField<scalar> is available in the database, it can be looked up using the mesh.thisDb().lookupObject<scalarField>("name") command.
Just a thought:
When you do scatter/gather, all the processors must be calling it at the same time, if not you will get an error.
So maybe some of the processor get stuck at earlier boundary conditions waiting for another global call or maybe boundaries with zero faces skip the scatter/gather operations.
I am not sure but just my thoughts.
Good evening Philip,
Thanks for the thoughts, which made me go back for a bit of testing. I downscaled a bit (using a less complex problem), so I took one of my wave boundary conditions, which are almost as simple as it gets.
I added the gather/scatter part and it fails.
I tried decomposing, such that all processors had faces on the particular boundary, and it fails.
I substituted the gather/scatter by a simple
It should be said that the last tests are done on another computer, so the problem seems to be portable. The problem only occurs, when I place the code snippet inside updateCoeffs(), and it does make it through the construction with a subsequent fail at the first encounter in the first time step.
Any ideas for better understanding this behaviour?
Can I ask you a question about gatherList and scatterList? In terms of their functions, are they similar to the MPI functions MPI_Gather and MPI_Scatter? Specifically:
MPI_Gather: collect the data from all the processors and then stores the collected data in one array in the root.
MPI_Scatter: send the data from the root to the other processors.
Is my understanding correct?
|All times are GMT -4. The time now is 15:14.|