CFD Online Discussion Forums

CFD Online Discussion Forums (
-   OpenFOAM Running, Solving & CFD (
-   -   Convergence problem residuals stay at a certain level (

andimb April 13, 2006 11:30

Hi! I still try to calculat

I still try to calculate the flow arround an airfoil and have a convergence problem. If I use another scheme then upwind all residuals decrease quite well but suddenly they increase to a certain level and stay there. The values of the solution are great (cl,cd,pressure distribution), but the residuals won't decrease.

I think the aspect ratio of the elements behind the airfoil is really bad, so it acts nearly like a wall. This could be a problem. Is there an other solution than use much more elements behind the profil which is uninteressting for me?
Or could it be another problem?
The values of the solution are really great, but I need the convergence for an automatic calculation.


andimb April 13, 2006 11:35

Hi! Sorry, I forgot to say,

Sorry, I forgot to say, I'm using a c-grid. That's the reason for the thin elements.


andimb April 27, 2006 03:56

Hi! Sorry, for starting thi

Sorry, for starting this thread new, but I'm still having the same problems. I reduced the mesh resolution so that there are no bad elements, but the convergence isn't better. The same behavior of the residuals. I tried other turbulence models to check if this is a problem. The only scheme for div(phi,U), which converge, is upwind.

Does anyone have an idea?


msrinath80 April 28, 2006 17:13

I've pasted some possible expl
I've pasted some possible explanations for the residual behavior you've observed. These are from the Fluent manual. Assuming your problem setup is correct, here are some possible reasons for the obseved behavior:

[1] If you have provided a very good initial guess, the residuals may not drop three orders of magnitude.

[2] If the governing equation contains non-linear source terms which are zero at the beginning of the calculation and build up slowly during computation, the residuals may not drop three orders of magnitude.

[3] If the variable of interest is nearly zero everywhere, the residuals may not drop three orders of magnitude. In fully-developed flow in a pipe, for example, the cross-sectional velocities are zero. If these velocities have been initialized to zero, initial (and final) residuals are both close to zero, and a three-order drop cannot be expected.

In such cases, it is wise to monitor integrated quantities, such as drag or overall heat transfer coefficient, before concluding that the solution has converged. It may also be useful to examine the un-normalized unscaled residual, and determine if the residual is small compared to some appropriate scale.

Hope this helps!

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 07:39.