CFD Online Discussion Forums

CFD Online Discussion Forums (http://www.cfd-online.com/Forums/)
-   OpenFOAM (http://www.cfd-online.com/Forums/openfoam/)
-   -   openfoam official repository for unsupported code (http://www.cfd-online.com/Forums/openfoam/110551-openfoam-official-repository-unsupported-code.html)

sail December 13, 2012 18:07

openfoam official repository for unsupported code
 
http://www.openfoam.org/contrib/unsupported.php

Well thats interesting. Looks like finally they decided to acept code from users while maintaing the author ownership. What do you think? And why there is no official announcement for this yet?

Also, i was just running through the docjmentation and i found it improved in term of content AND clarity. Well done!

Thanks to the OF team.

gschaider December 18, 2012 11:35

Quote:

Originally Posted by sail (Post 397448)
http://www.openfoam.org/contrib/unsupported.php

Well thats interesting. Looks like finally they decided to acept code from users while maintaing the author ownership. What do you think? And why there is no official announcement for this yet?

Also, i was just running through the docjmentation and i found it improved in term of content AND clarity. Well done!

Thanks to the OF team.

I haven't seen an announcement here on the Message Board. This either means:

- that it is not yet official
- they have no more interest in this line of communication

GRAUPS December 18, 2012 13:40

OpenFOAM Community Development
 
Forgive me if this is old news... but it looks like ESI and OpenCFD are trying to get a community development repository going on github.

http://www.openfoam.org/contrib/unsupported.php

It would be a great central location to store all of those custom solvers and awesome pieces of code that the community has created and that exist within the forums here on CFD online.

gschaider December 18, 2012 14:00

Quote:

Originally Posted by GRAUPS (Post 398133)
Forgive me if this is old news... but it looks like ESI and OpenCFD are trying to get a community development repository going on github.

http://www.openfoam.org/contrib/unsupported.php

It would be a great central location to store all of those custom solvers and awesome pieces of code that the community has created and that exist within the forums here on CFD online.

Well when such a project was proposed to them 5 or more years ago (openfoam-extend) they were not so keen about it.

I think we should wait until they properly announce it here on the MessageBoard (which in my opinion is still the main channel of communications for community matters. So if they don't discuss it here then they don't think that the initiative is ready for the community)

niklas December 18, 2012 14:02

its a nice initiative, but its gonna require alot of work to check the contributions before going in to the official version IF they decide to go down that path.

This way, they are making it possible for people to share and distribute without having to check for bugs. Its like having the cake and eating it too :)

Its been announced on the official forum - their homepage, this is not the main channel, even though we might feel so

sail December 18, 2012 16:35

Dear Bernhard,

I'm aware of the friction between OpenCfd and the userbase that happened in the past.

I just hope that internal pressure and/or a change of mindset and goals allows a change of heading in this regard.

I'm aware of the awesome developement made by the community and the dedicated users in the 1.6 extend branch but I'd really love to see all those efforts merged back in the main branch to take advantages of both the natural developement of the sw made by the profeasional OF team and the addition coming from the userbase.

gschaider December 18, 2012 17:35

Quote:

Originally Posted by sail (Post 398145)
Dear Bernhard,

I'm aware of the friction between OpenCfd and the userbase that happened in the past.

I just hope that internal pressure and/or a change of mindset and goals allows a change of heading in this regard.

I'm aware of the awesome developement made by the community and the dedicated users in the 1.6 extend branch but I'd really love to see all those efforts merged back in the main branch to take advantages of both the natural developement of the sw made by the profeasional OF team and the addition coming from the userbase.

That's what everybody wants. I just don't think that the occasional tweet and an announcement on the website is a good way to discuss such things. Until proven differently I assume that they wanted to announce it on the message board too and the other announcement slipped out early.

Linse December 19, 2012 07:38

Well, in my opinion there's too much interpretation into the fact that there is no "official" information within this forum here. Yes, it is probably the main point of information on OpenFOAM. But the real official location for information still is the homepage of the "vendor".
Maybe they just wanted to write more detailed information? Or maybe they already tried to contact some people from the extend-crowd?

While not having useful code additions yet, I think once I have something to be offered to the community, I will upload it to both repositories. Maybe at some point the different people manage to even synchronise the ESI and the extend-repositories concerning the development branch? Given proper mentioning of the developer, ESI anyhow could pull the extend-code into their release as well.

gschaider December 19, 2012 08:28

Quote:

Originally Posted by Linse (Post 398230)
Well, in my opinion there's too much interpretation into the fact that there is no "official" information within this forum here. Yes, it is probably the main point of information on OpenFOAM. But the real official location for information still is the homepage of the "vendor".
Maybe they just wanted to write more detailed information? Or maybe they already tried to contact some people from the extend-crowd?

Not to my knowledge (contacted the extend-people).

More detailed information: exactly my point. I'll wait till then

Quote:

Originally Posted by Linse (Post 398230)
While not having useful code additions yet, I think once I have something to be offered to the community, I will upload it to both repositories. Maybe at some point the different people manage to even synchronise the ESI and the extend-repositories concerning the development branch? Given proper mentioning of the developer, ESI anyhow could pull the extend-code into their release as well.

Well. There is the clause about handing over the "full copyright" in the preliminary announcement. I'd like to know what that means exactly. According to the talk by Bruce Perens at the OSCIC 12 it is one of the big myths that something like this is something that is necessary for OpenSource-projects to work properly.

But if you (and your employer) are fine with signing over your work unconditionally: alright

Don't get me wrong: I encourage people contributing there (or anywhere else where it is publicly available). I just don't see myself doing so right now


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 00:37.