CFD Online Discussion Forums

CFD Online Discussion Forums (
-   CFX (
-   -   Ansys tutorial (

slimmsk April 24, 2012 07:32

Ansys tutorial

Hello, :confused: :confused: :confused:
I seek a TUTORIAL to simulate a cylindrical flow of a Newtonian fluid by ANSYS and ANSYS CFX FLEUNT.

I tried with ANSYS FLUENT but I can not get a flow with constant velocity. I always accelerating throughout the cylinder which have no logic.

I tried with ANSYS CFX but I did not understand (there are chemical reactions that I did not need) and I want some help.

My account is:
My mail is:

Thank you for all

ghorrocks April 25, 2012 07:44

Your question raises more questions than it explains.

CFX and Fluent are both very capable CFD solvers. If they are doing weird things then you set them up wrong. Do more tutorials and training and things will be clearer.

You do not mention chemical reactions, so why are you saying CFX has chemical reactions you do not need.

Alternately if you want specific help on your simulation then post more detail and we will try to help.

slimmsk April 26, 2012 16:41


I try to simulate flow between two cylinders.

Normally I should get a constant velocity profile along the length.
But, I found an acceleration along the entire length of the cylinder.

Change speed / length axis> 0

normally it must be = 0

thank you


ghorrocks April 26, 2012 18:37

This effect is probably real - compressible flows accelerate along a duct due to the fluid density decreasing, all flows (incompressible and incompressible) have the centre line velocity accelerate as the boundary layer develops and the centre velocity accelerates to maintain constant volume flow rate.

slimmsk April 27, 2012 06:21

2 Attachment(s)

In one study, I found this Fig 1 (that is what I should normally find).
But I find a profile as in Fig 2

Attachment 12766

Attachment 12767

I can not find the trick. Is that it's normal?

I despair

Thank you for the help

ghorrocks April 27, 2012 06:33

You have not described what you are doing so I cannot help you. As I already said, this effect can be due to the boundary layer forming cuasing the centre line velocity to accelerate, or it could be the acceleration of the flow due to fricition in compressible flow. As I have no idea what you are modelling I cannot be more specific.

slimmsk April 28, 2012 04:48


You find this link in a description for what I did.
This is another topic that I posted.

If you have an article, a thesis or a study where I can find an explanation which I can pass it to me based retail?

thank you

ghorrocks April 29, 2012 07:00

Your flow is incompressible, so it appears the cause of the effect is development of the boundary layer causing acceleration of the core flow.

So this answers your question, doesn't it?

slimmsk April 29, 2012 15:33


yes, certainly for me, but I have to find a literature reference indicating the purpose in order to demonstrate the results that I present, and I can not find.

Thank you for your appreciable help and motivation for my question.

ghorrocks April 29, 2012 19:10

It is simple conservation of volume. No need for a reference, a few lines of maths proves it.

slimmsk May 1, 2012 05:47


if it is not too much, can you help me a little more. :confused:

thank you

ghorrocks May 1, 2012 19:18

Have a look at the flow at the inlet and the flow as it develops. See if you can work out why the centre line accelerates.

slimmsk May 6, 2012 20:03

1 Attachment(s)

how can I do to have a profile as in Figure 1. A constant speed over the entire length of the pipe.
Attachment 12948
The conditions requisent?

thank you

ghorrocks May 6, 2012 20:20

Just let the flow develop over a longer pipe.

slimmsk May 7, 2012 12:20


I'm working on a configuration such that the length L = 300mm and diameter D = 25.8 mm.
I tried with a length L = 500mm, but I found the same result.
even in simulating with a flow of water.:confused: :confused:

I tried with ANSYS CFX and it is similar, and I even found a constant mass flow along the pipe. :confused: :confused: :confused:

thank you

ghorrocks May 7, 2012 17:14

Have you done a 1D pipe flow analysis to estimate how long the flow development is likely to be?

slimmsk May 8, 2012 08:55

No, I work with stationary regime, no time in the calculation.

it is important to wear the transient calculation with a time interval? :(

thank you

ghorrocks May 8, 2012 21:23

Flow development occurs both in space and time - the boundary layer needs to grow even for a steady state flow as the flow progresses along the pipe. So work out the pipe lenght required to get developed flow, and I bet you will find your model is a tiny fraction of that.

In other words I think your problem is that your domain needs to be much longer to let the flow develop to fully developed.

slimmsk May 10, 2012 10:29


I tried a simulation with ANSYS Fluent (I still have some difficulty with CFX):

Inlet velocity
Outlet pressure with mass flow rate

Time step size: 60 seconds
Number of time step: 5
Number of iterations / time step: 300

I find the same result
I noticed that the solver resolves five blocks of 300 iterations each time, is it recalculates every time?

60 seconds is enough or must I fix a few minutes

thank you very much

ghorrocks May 10, 2012 23:59

Use the Fluent forum for questions on Fluent.

These are pretty basic questions you are asking - surely you know how to determine if the flow is developing in time or not.

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 01:00.