Basic explanation of turbulence models
I've been searching for a while for a low-level description of how the turbulence models work and am not finding very much. So far I have:
K-e: Uses turbulence energy (K) and it's rate of dissipation (e). Good standard model that works in most industrially relevant cases. Not good with: - flow reattachment - flow seperation - flow recovery SST: Uses K-e in free flow and K-w (w is the frequency of eddie currents) which is better for wall boundary layers. - bad with flow recovery after flow reattachment BSL: Baseline Reynolds Model? Can be used with a rougher mesh? SSG: Speziale-Sarkar-Gatski. Better than BSL for high Reynolds numbers? As you can see I have pretty much no information on BSL and SSG. Any information will be greatly appreciated! Cheers Ash :) |
Dear Ash,
I suggest that the help documentation of any CFD code may help you. For example, the section of "Turbulence Models" in CFX Modeling Guide offers a basic capability description of various turbulence models. And the Theory Guide tells how these turbulence models work. Sorry for no detailed information to help you. |
The turbulence modelling textbook "turbulence Modelling for CFD" by Wilcox is a excellent textbook in this area.
To correct some of your points: - k-e, has known problems at stagnation points, separations (both detactment and reattachment) but pretty good for bulk flows. Very poor at rotating flows and anisotropic turbulence. - SST - better at all these conditions, has models available which might help for rotating flows and turbulence transition and a few other special cases. This should be your default selection for a turbulence model unless you have a very good reason to choose something else. - All the Reynolds stress models - can capture flow rotation and anisotropic turbulence, but rarely end up being much more accurate than a reasonable 2-eqn model anyway due to the large number of assumptions required to get them to work. Also devilishly hard to converge. - And then there is DES, SAS, LES, DNS - these are advanced models which you should only consider when you have a good knowledge of turbulence models. Using them without knowing what they do is a receipe for disaster. |
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 05:00. |