CFD Online Discussion Forums

CFD Online Discussion Forums (
-   FLUENT (
-   -   How to reach steady state solution (

Sally June 7, 2007 01:34

How to reach steady state solution
Hello I am solving my case with unsteady state but I do not know in which time my solution reach a steady state is there anybody can guide me in this?


bashu June 7, 2007 11:11

Re: How to reach steady state solution
You should monitor several key variables (pressure, velocity) at some points and surfaces and once they reach a steady value the model is complete. For models which do not reach ss (multiphase, ..) you need to turn time averaging feature on and use the time average values. For those you need to time average it long enough to make sure the fluctuations are not effecting the time average results.

Sally June 7, 2007 11:36

Re: How to reach steady state solution
Hi bashu thanks to the reply can you tell me to how can i turn on time averaging feature because I was actually use multiphase flow in my simulations?

Thank you Sally

bashu June 7, 2007 13:44

Re: How to reach steady state solution
text command (for fluent 6.3, similar for prev. versions)

solve set d-s y 1 y y

or if running with gui check 'data sampling for time statistics' in the iterate window

Make sure you save the case file to be able to get the time average variables in the contour options.

Sally June 9, 2007 04:27

Re: How to reach steady state solution
Hi bashu I did what you told me about activating data sampling from the command. I was made a monitor to a point near the outlet of the pipe to look at the velocity, for this monitor I chose under every list flow time and for unsteady statistics I chose mean X velocity but for report type what you think the better choice as you think ? please let me know.

Thanks Sally

bashu June 11, 2007 14:11

Re: How to reach steady state solution
if you chose a point it really doesn't matter. I would choose are-weighted-average. if I understood right, you are monitoring the mean-x-velocity. if that's the case chances are that you will get an error. you need to do some iterations with the time-average on before turning the monitor on, since the mean values do not exist from beginning.

Sally June 12, 2007 05:00

Re: How to reach steady state solution
Hi bashu my monitor for x mean velocity now fluctuates between (1.1607-1.1608 m/sec) and this happened when the time reach (25 sec) and still fluctuate between these values even when I let the time reach (30 sec) is this mean I reach the steady state solution? knowing that I tried with both of vertex-average and area- weighted average it give the same thing?

Thank you Sally

bashu June 12, 2007 11:38

Re: How to reach steady state solution
if you plot the time average contours and you don't see sharp gradients of velocity, volume fraction and ...; your results should be steady now.

one other check is mass balance. you can look at the mass flow out for the time average period and the time average mass flow "in" should be equal to "out" for the period you are time averaging. if the mass "out" does not fluctuate, much then you should be OK

Sally June 13, 2007 02:37

Re: How to reach steady state solution
Hi bashu I failed to find the time average contours on the menu display >contours so where can I find it please? Furthermore how can I estimate the value of mass flow at inlet and outlet ? did you mean by the second way of check if the mass flow rate at outlet equal to mass flow rate at inlet I reach the steady state case?


bashu June 13, 2007 11:09

Re: How to reach steady state solution
you should see a new menu item 'unsteady statistics' and under that you will have the time average properties.

the mass flow in and out at any given time will not be equal in most multiphase transient cases. what you should do is to monitor the mass flow rate at the outlet and inlet and then plot them vs. time. if you time average these values over a range (outside fluent , in excel) the average values should be equal and the sum should be zero.

this means there is no accumulation of mass inside your system and what has entered eventually exited the ssytem. an alternative is to monitor totla volume fraction (which is mass if density is constant) and that should remain constant as well.

Sally June 14, 2007 09:26

Re: How to reach steady state solution
Well bashu I plot the contours for time average (from unsteady statistics menu) for mean x velocity,mean pressure it appear nearly the same for the last time steps with the same limits so what this mean ?

Thank you Sally

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 21:50.