Quote:
|
Why dont u do a 3D simulation and get a good result?????
even at small sizes, the trajectory of ure bubble is not necesserly vertical (unless it gets near a wall) I am not sure of the ranges of Re with in u get this behavior, but t is due to the instability of the vortex ring. The values of velocity that u are comparing with: are u sure that those experiences have been done in a very clean water???? in normal water, the behavior of bubbles is different. By exemple for stokes regime, the drag will be 24/Re, while it is 16/Re in a very clean water.... |
Can't blame him. Do you know which computational power he can access?
I'm pretty sure a 3D simulation with acceptable interface resolution will take days ... Lebaigue et. al. (http://test.interface.free.fr/Case01.pdf) have accomplished good results in 2D and Xilaf is simulation even smaller bubbles (and lower Reynolds) ... @Xilaf: What you should check is the approximation of the error the terminal velocity will have inside your domain: Equation (1.4) in the above paper. If this is in the range your bubble rises slower you may want to increase your computational domain. |
Divergence detected in AMG solver: x-momentum
hi dear all...
i was running fluent solving my 2D case after 35 time step an error message showed up (Divergence detected in AMG solver: x-momentum) i decreased under relaxation factor for momentum from 0.7 to 0.1 but again this message... i will be thankful if u share any similar experience:o |
Terminal vel
2 Attachment(s)
Quote:
@All I am also running simulations of similar nature. I would like to know how to find out the terminal velocity of the bubble in fluent. I got qualitative results of two bubbles rising in a tank (walls have free shear so that they do not affect the bubble). I want to know the Reynold's number. For that I need the terminal velocity. |
x-momentum
Quote:
i,ve tried all of this,i changed time step from 0.0001 to 1e-7 but no luck:o and about ur question:in my case rotational velocity is constant but i think u can read velocity from display>xy plot>velocity>... hope it helps |
Quote:
Also, for your problem, I read somewhere (cannot find the reference right now) that if your cell volume is less than 1e-6 cubic meter, then you could try with 3ddp version of fluent instead of 3d. Give it a try and let me know. It worked for me in one case. But have not required it again. |
Quote:
while ago i tried to open my 2D case with 3D fluent but i faced an error;i'll try that,tnx for ur suggestion:) |
Quote:
|
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 21:55. |