result on airfoil wortmann fx63-137 simulation
1 Attachment(s)
Hi,
I am doing a simulation on this airfoil to obtain the similar aerodynamic curve as from the literature http://www.worldofkrauss.com/foils/243 the maximum Cl is obtained at correct angle which is at 11 degree. However, the value is slightly off. The value obtained from simulation is Cl=1.7 while real Cl=2.013 from the website Cd=0.18 which is much higher than real Cd=0.05 Im using spalart allmaras and Re=1 million any advice is appreciated thanks attached is the Y+ plot on airfoil wall. And here is the url to download my mesh file http://www.sendspace.com/file/tld05b |
You won't be able to obtain the correct Cd with Spalart Allmaras, this is because the model, as implemented in Fluent, assumes the entire flow domain is turbulent which is not true.
For a short explanation check this article: http://larcase.etsmtl.ca/PDF/Note-Paul-f.pdf Do |
In Fluent 12 and 13 you can use a transition model, this will give you a better Cd.
|
thank you for the input DoHander, very much appreciated.
I've read the paper you gave and it seems that fully turbulent model on the entire domain is the reason for overprediction of Cd. So the overprediction is due to the skin friction alone or both pressure and friction drag? I'm using Fluent 6.3, so does fluent 6.3 has transition model? Or do i have to shift to version 12/13? How about the error in Cl (around 15%)? is it due to the meshing not being fine enough? thanks. |
Also your y+ values are very high. For accurate predictions you need to resolve the boundary layer. You will not be doing that with the mesh you currently have.
|
@jdfortune Fluent 6.3 doesn't have any transition model, you will need to switch to Fluent 12 or 13 if you want to use a transition model.
Also your mesh is bad, as swiftaircraft has noticed. If you want good results for Cd y+ must be less than 1 OR from 30 to 100. You can't use a mesh with y+ from 1 to 30 !!! My advice is to try to keep your y+ from 30 to 100, this will allow you to use a reasonable mesh (from a memory usage perspective). |
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 11:55. |