CFD Online Discussion Forums

CFD Online Discussion Forums (https://www.cfd-online.com/Forums/)
-   FLUENT (https://www.cfd-online.com/Forums/fluent/)
-   -   Cavitation model by A.K. Singhal (https://www.cfd-online.com/Forums/fluent/96243-cavitation-model-k-singhal.html)

neetu kumari January 17, 2012 04:42

Cavitation model by A.K. Singhal
 
Hello everyone

To simulate the cavitating flow, FLUENT has used A K Singhal's full cavitation model. But the model equations for rate of evaporation or condensation has inconsistency in dimensions. The correct unit of rate of evaporation or condensation should be kg/m3.s, but according to the above mentioned model equations the unit of that particular rate is coming as kg/m4 (by assuming that the empirical constants are dimensionless). If empirical constants have unit then what its value in particular SI unit and if not then how this could be possible?

If I have some misconceptions then please help me out.

Thank you.

shk12345 January 17, 2012 09:37

Can you share the paper which has the caviation model in it so that i can have a look at the dimension

regards
shk

neetu kumari January 18, 2012 00:54

Quote:

Originally Posted by shk12345 (Post 339748)
Can you share the paper which has the caviation model in it so that i can have a look at the dimension

regards
shk

Here is the full reference of that paper.

SINGHAL A.K., ATHAVALE M.M., HUIYING L., JIANG, L., 2002. Mathematical bases and validation of the full cavitation model. J Fluids Eng 124, 617-624.


Thanks

shk12345 January 18, 2012 03:22

Quote:

Originally Posted by neetu kumari (Post 339846)
Here is the full reference of that paper.

SINGHAL A.K., ATHAVALE M.M., HUIYING L., JIANG, L., 2002. Mathematical bases and validation of the full cavitation model. J Fluids Eng 124, 617-624.


Thanks

Hi
i tried to asses the journal but it is blocked at my place . I f you have acces to that paper can you send me that paper .

Regards
shk

Tingyun YIN February 26, 2018 06:21

Quote:

Originally Posted by neetu kumari (Post 339680)
Hello everyone

To simulate the cavitating flow, FLUENT has used A K Singhal's full cavitation model. But the model equations for rate of evaporation or condensation has inconsistency in dimensions. The correct unit of rate of evaporation or condensation should be kg/m3.s, but according to the above mentioned model equations the unit of that particular rate is coming as kg/m4 (by assuming that the empirical constants are dimensionless). If empirical constants have unit then what its value in particular SI unit and if not then how this could be possible?

If I have some misconceptions then please help me out.

Thank you.

Hi, buddy. Now I have the same problem about the unit. How do you solve it? Any comments are appreciated.

jcw August 23, 2021 04:19

Hello!
(1) I also read A. K. Singhal paper and I came across the same question about the SI-units of Rc and Re. If Cc and Ce are dimensionless, Rc and Re have SI-unit of [kg/m⁴]. I am expecting SI-unit of [kg/(m³s)]. It is also written in the paper, that Rc and Re are 'phase change rates'. So, there should be Time (s) included in SI-unit of Rc and Re.
(2) fg: Is there a model how to implement a transport equation for non-condensable gas (fg)? In my opinion, fg varies in fluid domain and depends on absolute pressure.

I am posting this to ANSYS/Fluent Forum, as I am continuing this thread. But this is a comprehension question, independent of solver. I am glad to read your comments.


Thanks for feedback.

jcw September 6, 2021 04:33

Non-condensable gas transport equation
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jcw (Post 810809)
Hello!
(1) I also read A. K. Singhal paper and I came across the same question about the SI-units of Rc and Re. If Cc and Ce are dimensionless, Rc and Re have SI-unit of [kg/m⁴]. I am expecting SI-unit of [kg/(m³s)]. It is also written in the paper, that Rc and Re are 'phase change rates'. So, there should be Time (s) included in SI-unit of Rc and Re.
(2) fg: Is there a model how to implement a transport equation for non-condensable gas (fg)? In my opinion, fg varies in fluid domain and depends on absolute pressure.

I am posting this to ANSYS/Fluent Forum, as I am continuing this thread. But this is a comprehension question, independent of solver. I am glad to read your comments.


Thanks for feedback.

Hello!

Finally, I found one paper (Modelling and Validation of Cavitating Orifice Flow in Hydraulic Systems, P. Casoli) which is dealing with the transport equations for non-condensable gas. I am struggeling with the definition of the mentioned equilibrium differential pressure, as used in eqn. 5. Can someone help?

Thanks and regards.


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 18:30.