steady state  transient
Hello CFDfriends. A short problem description: flow through a baffle, simple geometry like an elbow divided in several channels, Newtonian, incompressible,2D, inletvelocity = 24.9 m/s, pressure outlet, fine and good mesh,structured in near wall regions, discretisation scheme: only firstorder accurate, nu = 2,8e5. Analysing the solution brought out big differences in the calculated pressure loss between the steadystate and the transient solution. Has anyone ever experienced huge differences (pressure loss nearly twice as high) between steadystate and transient simulation although the final residuals are of order 1e7. The flow is obviously unsteady.

Re: steady state  transient
100% is a large difference. I am assuming the unsteady loss is the higher one?

Re: steady state  transient
No, the unsteady solution reports a pressure loss of 220 Pa, the steadystate simulation gives a value of 330 Pa. Meanwhile I changed discretisation scheme to second order, but the great differences remain. Software: OpenFoam, solver: simpleFoam  unsteady; turbFoam  transient. Any advice?

Re: steady state  transient
It's hard to give advice other than to make sure that the computations are not just converged, but have also been checked for accuracy (experimental data would be invaluable!). Try increasing grid resolution and temporal resolution (unsteady) to the point where the solution doesn't change any more, and make sure your boundary conditions are suitable. Closely examine the unsteady solution (what actually happens over time  is there some kind of flow instability... some kind of oscillation... ).
One thing that's suspect is the fact that the steady state gives higher losses. I can imagine the opposite situation: if there really is unsteadiness such as a vortex instability, then the creation of vorticity over time will likely be seen as additional loss as compared to the steady state. However, in your case I couldn't trust either steady state or unsteady result. A closer look at both solutions should help to see if either of them actually makes sense. 
All times are GMT 4. The time now is 20:31. 