CFD Online Discussion Forums

CFD Online Discussion Forums (
-   Main CFD Forum (
-   -   larminar flow doesn't change into turbulent flow (

dh September 3, 2008 03:31

larminar flow doesn't change into turbulent flow

i'm coding unsteady rans channel flow(k-epsilon, Ret=180) but turbulence doesn't appear. it converges larminar flow..... i don't know why it does. i need your help.

sensor September 5, 2008 21:04

Re: larminar flow doesn't change into turbulent fl

Here are two possibilities:

(1) your algorithm is overly dissipative (which is not a good situation);

(2) Keep in mind: larminar flow is a possible solution to the NS system. Add much larger random fluctuations to your initial field, and then let the field gradually converges to a steady state turbulent field.

d.h. September 6, 2008 21:08

Re: larminar flow doesn't change into turbulent fl
Hi Thank you for your response.

It seems that my case is (1) among possibilities you give.

May I know the ratio nu(kinematic viscosity) to nut(eddy viscosity)? And I want to konw the initial condition of kinetic energy(k) and eddy dissipation ratio(epsilon).

sensor September 11, 2008 23:32

Re: larminar flow doesn't change into turbulent fl
Sorry I thought you were doing LES or DNS. But, in any case, do not give up easily. Since you are using k-epsilon model, I assume it is steady RANS. Check you k- and epsilon-equations and also the eddy viscosity model, and see if they are coded correctly. Check, e.g., the calculation of the strain rate tensor.

The case of Re_tau=180 is a very classical one. You can find the ratio between nu and nu_t in, e.g., ``Turbulent Flows'' by S. Pope. If I remember clearly, nu_t/nu is about 36 at the center of the channel.

Just my curiosity: if this is for basic training (e.g., course study), it is fine. But if this is for your PhD research, not good. You should be provided a basic code which can do this classical benchmark test case, at least. Otherwise,,,

dh September 26, 2008 01:29

Re: larminar flow doesn't change into turbulent fl
Thank you for your advice~ Actually I have studied hybrid RANS-LES model. Unsteady problem is terrible thing itself..... T T Now turbulence is generated thank to your help but the result is not good. I want to know the periodic boundary condition for pp. When soving Poisson eq., how are coefficients, ae, aw(steamwise direction), ad, au (spanwise direction) treated for SIMPLE algorithm?

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 17:21.