A different view
Consider the "visuals" of the following:
1/ "Standard" wind tunnel wing c/w streamlines. - At low AoA the air is leaving the trailing edge at an angle of -say- 15 degrees below horizontal 2/ A helicopter rotor in the horizontal plane. - At low blade AoA the airflow is STRAIGHT DOWN So why the difference? In 1/ the air is moving over the stationary wing In 2/ the wing is "cutting" through the stationary air Why in "all" textbooks is option 1/ chosen? Maybe this was the "standard" and "only" option before CFD visuals. Why not use CFD to promote the visuals of option 2 which in my opinion is the more "truthful" option since in the end lift is the reaction force to air being "forced" vertically downward by the "wing". |
Re: A different view
OP again.
Support for this "view" can be found in this excellent paper BUT no CFD support to produce option 2/ views. http://www.aa.washington.edu/faculty.../Lift_AAPT.pdf |
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 07:16. |