CFD Online Discussion Forums

CFD Online Discussion Forums (
-   Main CFD Forum (
-   -   Why structured grid approach more accurate (

Lam June 19, 2003 16:18

Why structured grid approach more accurate
Why does unstructured grid approach is more accurate than structured grid approach? I appreciate your opinions?

Tamer June 19, 2003 20:35

Re: Why structured grid approach more accurate
In fact I feel that the other way around is the correct. The structured grid approach should be more accurate if it utilize the same grid quality in the high gradient solution zones. The reason for that is the interpolation schemes utilized are more consistant and the intergration along the faces in FV formulation should be of second order or close to second order if the grid is not uniform. Where as the order of the discretization is hard to keep in second order in the unstructured meshes.

centaur_ks June 20, 2003 10:46

Re: Why structured grid approach more accurate
also.. consider the memory requirement for unstructured grid compared with structured grid for a large and complicated geometry.


Ted June 24, 2003 11:08

Re: Why structured grid approach more accurate
Even if your discussions of order were correct, that would not make sense. The order of accuracy refers to an asymptotic process of grid refinement, such that the grid distribution function remains unchanged. For any given grid, any method (e.g. first order) can be more or less accurate than another discretization method (e.g. third order). Since in practice one can rarely reach the level of refinement when asymptotic relations hold, this is in fact the most common occurence, when 1st order method can be more accurate than higher order discretizations especially for rapidly varying problems. For a simple of model of that, check out the curve fitting with different polynomials.

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 23:34.