CFD Online Discussion Forums

CFD Online Discussion Forums (
-   Main CFD Forum (
-   -   Best CFD for Free Surface Application (

Onda April 16, 2009 02:25

Best CFD for Free Surface Application

My company is looking to buy a CFD Package mainly for Free Surface applications. (Floating bodies)
We are looking for a complete package (mesh + pre/post + analysis). The code should run on a X86-64 machine.

I would like to know pro and cons of most common commercial software as CFX, Fluent, Star-CCM+, Flow3D, OpenFoam (free!), regarding this particolar application.

I have some experience done on my previous job with CFX but we would like to have a general idea on what is present on market. I'm interested to know also the ease of use of the GUI compared to CFX,

Any code have a build in routine to manage body dinamics?
If not, how to do the routine? Fortran? Visual Basic?

If somebody can give me a price for a complete package this will be helpfull too.
I'm interestd also on the price of additional solver license tu run parallel.

Thanks in advance
Onda :)

A_Lyaskin April 16, 2009 05:10

STAR-CCM+ handles floating bodies via DFBI technology, but I don't have any hands on experience myself. Check this example:
There're also some other articles at CD-Adapco web site.

Onda April 18, 2009 02:41


Thanks for the link, is usefull to understand what Star CCM+ can do.
I found a preview on CFX12, have integrated same capability.
Now i would like to have some consideration on which software is better for this particular application and why!

NaMe April 18, 2009 04:39

Try to check Marine Report of Cd-adapco. Then You will decide to buy Cd-adapco's CFD Packages :)
STAR-CCM+ is number one for similar simulations..:D

you can find marine report in web site of cd-adapco.

radiatn April 19, 2009 22:49

Try to ask the people of all these codes about a need to change the water level without having to re-mesh everything i.e. doing it by simply changing the BC or model setups and not having to re-mesh. It might be advantageous to you.

Onda April 20, 2009 06:22

On my previous work with CFX the water level was set with a Step function on boundary and the trim (change in angle of water level in respect to the boat) was done with a rotation of a CS. So no need of remesh!
I hope this could be done in any software!


All times are GMT -4. The time now is 01:15.