CFD Online Discussion Forums

CFD Online Discussion Forums (
-   Main CFD Forum (
-   -   BL seperation of flow over cylinder (

vishnukmd7 January 3, 2012 07:11

BL seperation of flow over cylinder
Can someone give the the solution/direct me to a solution ( I need a karman-pohlhausen solution, not a cfd solution) of point of seperation in a laminar steady flow over a cylinder?

I tried solving as given BLT by Schlichting (Chp.12), but I'm getting point of seperation as 90 degree, when its told that it should be 76. Can someone give me a the correct solution??

( steady flow assumption, third order approximation of velocity, U(s)=2Uinf sin(\varphi),\varphi=r\vartheta )

If possible, when you are refering papers, limit them to ASME/Sciencedirect. My institute doesnt subscribe to many journals.

duri January 4, 2012 14:39

Laminar flow over cylinder starts to separate at 90deg. Due to upstream propagation of pressure disturbance separation point moves upstream to some extant. Boundary layer equations are parabolic in nature, upstream propagation is not possible with boundary layer equations.

vishnukmd7 January 4, 2012 14:43

err...thats not correct. Theoretical answers are varying for some reason from 104 to 76 :|. I found this paper [ classic ] on cylinders that gives 104 degree seperation point but in another published about 2 years later on by NACA its about 80, and in BLT text, i found it as 76 degree. Can someone verify why the results are varying?? and what is the experimental value??

duri January 4, 2012 15:46

Don't get confused by experimental results. Paper you given is over ellipse and not on cylinder. Try to understand the mathematical properties of BL equation. In favorable pressure gradient, boundary layer equation won't give zero shear stress. :)

vishnukmd7 January 4, 2012 15:48

:) thank you for your help. If you take the limiting case for eccentricity = 1, what you get is the cylinder solution.

agd January 4, 2012 17:11

For a circular cylinder, laminar flow will separate at roughly 80 deg. The laminar boundary equation solutions using a Pohlhausen type approximation and an inviscid pressure distribution give results around 108 deg. The reason for the discrepancy is that the pressure distribution is far from the inviscid profile past the separation point, and laminar flow is very susceptible to small adverse pressure gradients. Under ideal condtions, the flow may not separate until 108 deg, but in practice it will separate well ahead of 90 deg.

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 17:20.