|November 7, 2011, 12:04||
foamCalc/heat flux problem
Join Date: Jul 2011
Posts: 28Rep Power: 7
I'm trying to validate and report the heat flux using foamCalc for a "flow of oil over plate" problem, using the buoyantBoussinesqSimpleFoam solver. But I'm getting different values after used foamCalc magGrad T utility.
L=5m for length and h= 1m width =1m but I'm testing with 2d case.
I have done several meshes, from a super coarse to ultra refined mesh with scaling, I also have calculated the first cell height.
The problem is that with some meshes I get values really similar to the analitic solution (about 3% error) but If I change the mesh dimension I get other values of magGrad T, this values are "similar" to the correct values but it seems that this values are multiplicated/divided by an natural number.
The analitic solution gives:
Fine mesh of 7500 volumes ( 150 for x and 50 for y with scalling first cell heigth =0.00507462)
Plate: magGrad T=15763.186 K/m --> multiplication by k=0.144 and the plate lenght gives q"=11349.4945152 W ( unitary lenght) this is 2.8% of error.
20000 Volumes mesh (200*100 with scalling FCL=0.000331119)
Plate: magGrad T=183675.96985 K/m absolutly out of merge, but if you divide this value by 12 (why 12!!! ) get 15306.33 K/m --> multiplication by k=0.144 and the plate lenght gives q"=11020.558191 this is 0.178% of error
I will upload the case file soon!
Thanks for reading and sorry about my english!!!
|November 17, 2011, 03:45||
Re: heat flux problem
Join Date: Jul 2011
Posts: 18Rep Power: 7
The different magGrad T values really seem to be strange and I don't know the reason. Do you get the same results with wallHeatFluxLaminar instead of magGrad?
I experienced that magGrad and wallHeatFluxLaminar give wrong results when a groovyBC is applied to the surface - but with a fixedValue boundary condition, it works fine also for different meshes in my studies.
|Thread||Thread Starter||Forum||Replies||Last Post|
|Wind turbine simulation||Saturn||CFX||45||February 8, 2016 05:42|
|Problem in implementing cht||tilek||CFX||3||May 8, 2011 08:39|
|Heat flux in ansys cfx||juliom||OpenFOAM Running, Solving & CFD||2||April 14, 2009 14:30|
|What is the problem with the relative Flux Correction||danielle||OpenFOAM Running, Solving & CFD||0||November 2, 2008 00:24|
|Flux calculation in vertex-centered finite volume.||Martin||Main CFD Forum||3||June 4, 2008 10:04|