Mesh independence studies
Hey
I am trying to understand the mesh convergence while using interFOAM. So what is have seen are two methods where tthe interface shape is compared after a certain time and the other option is to use Grid Convergence Index (GCI) like described in http://www.grc.nasa.gov/WWW/wind/val.../spatconv.html I am trying to figure out GCI method I got confused after looking at how it is used in literature. So I was hoping someone can help it me out :) What I understood about GCI is that: |
Yes, continue....
|
Mesh independence studies
Sorry.. I couldn't edit the post earlier due to some network problem.
So what I understood about GCI is that
where r is the ratio of the mesh size between the meshes used (greater than 1). This is dependent on the solution methods and is usually lower than 2 because of non-linearities in the governing equations.
This GCI is for 'fine' mesh. And F is factor of safety.
Please let me know if I misunderstood something so far :) Now my questions are:
|
Yes, GCI is a relative error, you can interpret it like an error bar.
Say you have 3 grids, coarse, medium, fine. In Roache's proposed method, your working grid is the coarse grid. The purpose of running a medium and fine grid is purely for calculating the GCI and you never see these grids again. Now this sounds silly to a lot of people. Because why would I not utilize the superior results of the finest available grid? Why take results from the coarsest and not finest grid? More technically, it has to do with the way the Richardson extrapolation. You don't need to extrapolate per se when you are using a coarse grid (because you have a medium grid). But if you are using a fine grid, then you have to extrapolate because you don't have a finer grid. Hence, you will find two different methods for GCI calculation. One with the coarse grid as a reference and another with the fine grid as a reference. You can pick the approach that you prefer, just use the right formulas. |
Quote:
Thank you for the quick reply! Can you recommend a place I can learn more about for calculating GCI and mesh sensitivity tests in literature apart from Roache's work? Thanks again in advance:) |
Well, Patrick Roache is the one that came up with the GCI method. I can't think of a better place to learn specifically about this technique. Roache also write several (pretty thick) books on this topic.
|
A brief description is also in the Peric & Ferziger textbook
|
Thank you for the suggestions! :)
|
Hey again
As you suggested I was going through the work by Roache and I came across : Procedure for Estimation and Reporting of Uncertainty Due to Discretization in CFD Applications, Journal of Fluids engineering (ASME). They have described each steps. I have few additional questions:
|
All times are GMT -4. The time now is 13:45. |