On the harmonic interpolation scheme for the diffusivity coefficient

vkrastev · December 16, 2010, 09:35

Hi all,
browsing the forum recently I've found in an old post that in our beloved code (OpenFOAM) there is the possibility to use the harmonic interpolation scheme (rather than the classical linear scheme) for the evaluation of the diffusivity coefficient on the cell faces. Well, knowing from Patankar's book that when there could be abrupt changes in the diffusivity coefficient the harmonic interpolation scheme behaves much better than the linear one, I started to think about two questions: 1) why the harmonic option for the laplacian schemes is so rarely cited in this forum? 2) if any of you has some experience about it, does this choice give any significant improvements in turbulent flows calculations (where, in principle, the effective diffusivity coefficients should have significant changes from a point to the neighbour ones)? And if so, does it give any stability issues?
Every opinion/contribution about this matter would be really appreciated.

Thank you in advance

V.

vkrastev · December 18, 2010, 09:50

Mmmmh...so it seems like I'm the only one who has read this passage of Patankar's CFD book?

kathrin_kissling · April 11, 2011, 08:38

Hi Vesselin,

did you have any more information about this topic?
Did you get this to run?

I'm thinking about using the harmonic scheme as well.

Best

kathrin

benk · April 11, 2011, 08:52

I use harmonic interpolation mostly because I have sharp changes in the transport coefficient between regions in my model. In my model I was having big problems before I thought of using the harmonic scheme: I made some comparisons here (and in some posts above this one): http://www.cfd-online.com/Forums/ope...tml#post253611

I think most people don't use harmonic interpolation because they don't have sharp changes in the transport coefficient. The best thing to do is to try it to see if it changes your solution.

kathrin_kissling · April 11, 2011, 09:02

Hi ben!

Thank you for your reply!
I will definitly give it a try!

Kathrin

vkrastev · April 11, 2011, 09:13

Hi Kathrin, I think that Ben's answer can be considered quite exhaustive. This kind of interpolation was indeed introduced in finite volume calculation to account for very sharp changes in the diffusive transport coefficient (think about heat conduction through anisotropic or in general composite materials). Concerning CFD, I can tell you that for High-Re incompressible turbulent flows (RANS/URANS modeling, without heat transfer) I've found no benefits in using harmonic interpolation instead of the linear one (in addition the harmonic scheme seems to be slightly more unstable). Of course, things may be different when heat transfer is involved, so you have definitely to try it for your case!

Regards

V.

December 16, 2010, 09:35	On the harmonic interpolation scheme for the diffusivity coefficient	#1
vkrastev Senior Member Vesselin Krastev Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: University of Tor Vergata, Rome Posts: 368 Rep Power: 20	Hi all, browsing the forum recently I've found in an old post that in our beloved code (OpenFOAM) there is the possibility to use the harmonic interpolation scheme (rather than the classical linear scheme) for the evaluation of the diffusivity coefficient on the cell faces. Well, knowing from Patankar's book that when there could be abrupt changes in the diffusivity coefficient the harmonic interpolation scheme behaves much better than the linear one, I started to think about two questions: 1) why the harmonic option for the laplacian schemes is so rarely cited in this forum? 2) if any of you has some experience about it, does this choice give any significant improvements in turbulent flows calculations (where, in principle, the effective diffusivity coefficients should have significant changes from a point to the neighbour ones)? And if so, does it give any stability issues? Every opinion/contribution about this matter would be really appreciated. Thank you in advance V.

Thread Tools	Search this Thread
Show Printable Version Email this Page	Search this Thread: Advanced Search
Display Modes
Linear Mode Switch to Hybrid Mode Switch to Threaded Mode

Similar Threads
Thread	Thread Starter	Forum	Replies	Last Post
fvc::interpolate -> harmonic interpolation?	gwierink	OpenFOAM Running, Solving & CFD	8	October 1, 2012 13:31
solution diverges when linear upwind interpolation scheme is used	subash	OpenFOAM	0	May 29, 2010 01:23
vanLeer Interpolation Scheme with interFoam	rassilon	OpenFOAM Running, Solving & CFD	0	April 8, 2010 02:51
Automotive test case	vinz	OpenFOAM Running, Solving & CFD	98	October 27, 2008 08:43
CAVITATION (pressure interpolation scheme)!?	ROOZBEH	FLUENT	0	March 3, 2004 03:26

December 18, 2010, 09:50		#2
vkrastev Senior Member Vesselin Krastev Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: University of Tor Vergata, Rome Posts: 368 Rep Power: 20	Mmmmh...so it seems like I'm the only one who has read this passage of Patankar's CFD book?

April 11, 2011, 08:38		#3
kathrin_kissling Senior Member Kathrin Kissling Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: Besigheim, Germany Posts: 134 Rep Power: 17	Hi Vesselin, did you have any more information about this topic? Did you get this to run? I'm thinking about using the harmonic scheme as well. Best kathrin

April 11, 2011, 08:52		#4
benk Senior Member Ben K Join Date: Feb 2010 Location: Ottawa, Canada Posts: 140 Rep Power: 19	I use harmonic interpolation mostly because I have sharp changes in the transport coefficient between regions in my model. In my model I was having big problems before I thought of using the harmonic scheme: I made some comparisons here (and in some posts above this one): http://www.cfd-online.com/Forums/ope...tml#post253611 I think most people don't use harmonic interpolation because they don't have sharp changes in the transport coefficient. The best thing to do is to try it to see if it changes your solution.

April 11, 2011, 09:02		#5
kathrin_kissling Senior Member Kathrin Kissling Join Date: Mar 2009 Location: Besigheim, Germany Posts: 134 Rep Power: 17	Hi ben! Thank you for your reply! I will definitly give it a try! Kathrin

April 11, 2011, 09:13		#6
vkrastev Senior Member Vesselin Krastev Join Date: Jan 2010 Location: University of Tor Vergata, Rome Posts: 368 Rep Power: 20	Hi Kathrin, I think that Ben's answer can be considered quite exhaustive. This kind of interpolation was indeed introduced in finite volume calculation to account for very sharp changes in the diffusive transport coefficient (think about heat conduction through anisotropic or in general composite materials). Concerning CFD, I can tell you that for High-Re incompressible turbulent flows (RANS/URANS modeling, without heat transfer) I've found no benefits in using harmonic interpolation instead of the linear one (in addition the harmonic scheme seems to be slightly more unstable). Of course, things may be different when heat transfer is involved, so you have definitely to try it for your case! Regards V.