CFD Online Discussion Forums

CFD Online Discussion Forums (
-   Siemens (
-   -   High residuals (

ecram November 25, 2008 14:26

High residuals
Hello, I have a new question for You, in my simulation of wing in free flux, the residual are high but the result in terms of Cl and Cp is good which it is the reason?


no one November 25, 2008 23:17

Re: High residuals
The magnitude of the residuals is not important, they are pretty arbitrary. I think Star-CD and Star-CCM+ normalize your residuals by the largest change in any cell from iteration 0 to iteration 1. If the initial conditions were very close to the solution, then your residuals will be normalized by a very small number, making the residuals high. The thing to look out for is increasing or oscillating residuals that could indicated mesh or setup problems. Monitoring values like Cp and Cl as you have done is a much better gauge of convergence. Residuals are a better indicator of mesh quality than convergence.

ecram November 26, 2008 04:43

Re: High residuals
Thank you very much hour I am most calmer

James November 26, 2008 09:19

Re: High residuals
At least in 3.26 you can turn ANORM on.

This turns the residual methodology back to the former physics based system, used before they decided that they needed to be like Fluent.

For most of the variables this ends up being the sum of all fluxes through the cell walls normalized by the inlet flux.

The absolute value is related to the inlet flux to volume of the model, but at least it means something physical.

I believe they changed because Fluent was 'easier' and 'faster' to converge. Since you have no real idea what these numbers mean if the number was low then you can pretend that it is converged if it asymptotes.

It is somewhat strange that if you have a bad initial guess you can converge faster (fewer iterations) than if you mapped a full solution. In the first case the initial residuals are very poor and can be reduced fast, in the second case you may be very near convergence and thus they should not change much.

All times are GMT -4. The time now is 18:36.