
[Sponsors] 
February 21, 2004, 18:48 
Airfoil negative drag coefficent

#1 
Guest
Posts: n/a

Hi, I am modelling a 2D airfoil in Fluent (using segregated 2nd order solver) and as I increase the angle of attack the drag (due to pressure) is decreasing. At angles greated than 10 degrees this drag force becomes negative  i.e. producing thrust!!!!! If a turbulence model is added the pressure drag still outweighs the viscous drag so overall drag is still negative. This is obviously not correct  can anybody shed any light on this? It's quite urgent as I have to write a report on this by next week. It seems that only the upper airfoil surface is producing negative drag which is also strange. I am quite confident that the quality of the mesh is good  I'm baffled! Thanks for any help anyone can offer.
James. 

February 21, 2004, 23:41 
Re: Airfoil negative drag coefficent

#2 
Guest
Posts: n/a

First question that comes to my mind is whether your equation for drag is correct. This equation will involve the surface normal; if the direction of normal is wrong then you will get the wrong sign. If the magnitude of the drag seems correct except for the sign then this is most likely the problem. Then just reverse the direction of the normal.


February 22, 2004, 06:16 
Re: Airfoil negative drag coefficent

#3 
Guest
Posts: n/a

Thanks for your reply. I don't think this is the problem as at zero angle of attack the drag is in the correct direction. It is only once I begin to increase the angle that drag decreases, then passes through zero and becomes negative. The drag vector is set to act in the positive x direction. The thing I find strange is that, for example, at 10 degrees AoA the drag on the bottom surface is positive, but the drag on the upper surface is a larger negative value. The net sum of these two forces leads to the negative drag coefficient.


February 22, 2004, 12:33 
Re: Airfoil negative drag coefficent

#4 
Guest
Posts: n/a

James
I'm sure you have got your vectors wrong somewhere! Obviously the force will be in the correct direction at zero incidence when alpha = 0 even if you have the sin's and cos's wrong! Send me the files if you still have a problem. I assume you're either doing aeronautics or ship science at soton! Regards James 

February 23, 2004, 01:03 
Re: Airfoil negative drag coefficent

#5 
Guest
Posts: n/a

James,
You did convert axial force and normal force to lift and drag via L=Fy cos(alpha)  Fx sin(alpha) D=Fx cos(alpha) + Fy sin(alpha) didn't you? (refer to aerodynamics 101 ....) 

February 23, 2004, 02:10 
Re: Airfoil negative drag coefficent

#6 
Guest
Posts: n/a

Well, I solved the problem last night by simply rotating the grid by the required number of degrees. However, when using the above formula on data I had obtained previously, that also works! I think the problem was that I assumed Fluent already did that calculation when displaying lift and drag forces  I overlooked the fact that forces acting in the x and y directions were not necessarily acting parallel and normal to the oncoming flow.
Thanks to all that helped out! James. 

April 2, 2010, 16:44 
the problem could turn out to be as simple as

#7 
New Member
Join Date: Feb 2010
Posts: 3
Rep Power: 16 
Hi there
i have spent some time now getting used to fluent it is fairly simple for the most part but the devil is in the detail, i have been undertaking a comparison between 2d and 3d aerofoil cfd results in fluent, for the 3d models i change the coordinate system premeshing to allow for changes in AOA but for the 2D models i just changed the flow direction accordingly in boundary conditions>>velocity,direction and magnitude. this brought about some very strange results from the forces monitors for Cl and Cd. To cut to the chase, lift is taken to be as perpendicular to the freestream flow and drag is taken to be parallel to the flow. so for my 3d models the flow was always coming into the flow domain horizontally so i had no problems like receiving negative drag ( the chance would be a fine thing), this only occurred when i changed the flow direction in the 2d models. simply change the force vectors in the force monitors to: for lift x=sin(alpha) y=cos(alpha) drag x=cos(alpha) y=sin(alpha) i hope this helps, 

April 9, 2011, 07:06 

#8 
Member
Aamer Shahzad
Join Date: Mar 2010
Posts: 58
Rep Power: 16 
HI lfc....
it is true that lift and drag components will be, the way you wrote, for an incomg flow.... but what will be done , if there is a case in which motion is in still air... .....For instance.... If i am rotating (azimuth motion) my wing in a still air from o to pi radians, through udf (i.e no inflow velocity). Assume that the wing is given constant angle of attack of 20 degree by tilting the whole grid. Now how will the components of lift and drag be given to fluent ???? 

March 8, 2016, 09:31 

#9 
New Member
Limam
Join Date: Feb 2016
Posts: 1
Rep Power: 0 
Hi, I'm simulating drag and lift coefficient of flow around a cylinder but my drag coefficient keep fluctuating between negative and positive value and some time it is even negative, is this possible and if yes what is the cause behind this, thank you in advance please help.


September 5, 2022, 10:30 

#10  
New Member
Mehulbhai Sasvadiya
Join Date: Jan 2021
Location: Germany
Posts: 25
Rep Power: 5 
Quote:
Hello, I am doining 2D airfoil simulation in pimpleFOAM. My Freeesteam Velocity is coming from in Ydiection from downward to upward direction. So my drag force is perpendicular to the free stream velocity and parallel to the lift force. So is it possible to get negative drag force, because I got negative drag force. Thanks. 

Thread Tools  Search this Thread 
Display Modes  


Similar Threads  
Thread  Thread Starter  Forum  Replies  Last Post 
channelFoam for a 3D pipe  AlmostSurelyRob  OpenFOAM  3  June 24, 2011 13:06 
[blockMesh] BlockMesh FOAM warning  gaottino  OpenFOAM Meshing & Mesh Conversion  7  July 19, 2010 14:11 
negative airfoil drag??  Robin  FLUENT  4  January 7, 2010 16:29 
airfoil optimizer chain with drag problem  Arnolm  OpenFOAM Running, Solving & CFD  2  October 18, 2009 13:43 
[blockMesh] Axisymmetrical mesh  Rasmus Gjesing (Gjesing)  OpenFOAM Meshing & Mesh Conversion  10  April 2, 2007 14:00 